03 July, 2008

Fear of Flying

I got a note from a friend of mine in Australia recently. Regarding flying, he said.. "Would like to try it some time, though reading some of the other more recent posts makes me wonder how safe it really is!"

He was referring to posts I have written on this blog that mention accidents and incidents and, understandably it has raised a good deal of concern with him (and, no doubt, with other readers of his blog)


Let me tell you, there is nothing to be scared of when it comes to flying. Statistically it is still the safest way to travel. Statistically you are more likely to be hit by a meteor than be killed while flying (I'm not sure if that's true, but it illustrates a point!)

However: It is a well known fact that there are plane crashes every year. In fact there are quite a few plane crashes every year. A lot of them don't get talked about too much (small planes crashing in wilderness etc.). Some of them make the news, but not all (Colin McRae's helicopter crash last year and the Cessna Citation jet that crashed in Kent killing racing driver John Leslie). Mostly these get publicity more for the people who were on board than for the accident itself.

But there are, occasionally, large accidents that get coverage due to the sheer scale. The largest accident on record was the crash between two 747's on the tarmac at Tenerife in the 1970's. The Lockerbie bombing in the 80's and the 4 jets that went down on September 11th 2001 were terrorist attacks rather than accidents. TWA 800, the 747 that blew up over Long Island was an electrical short circuit.. the list goes on and on.

So let's put this in perspective. According to the National Safety Council, who have been logging US safety-related accidents since 1920, the odds of dying in an air or space related accident in the US in 2004 were 1 in 432,484. Compare this with the odds of dying in a car (1 in 19,216), pick-up truck (1 in 75,142) or as a pedestrian (1 in 49,139). What about "Inhalation and ingestion of other objects causing obstruction of respiratory tract" (1 in 91,340) or "Accidental poisoning by and exposure to noxious substances" (1 in 14,017) or "Assault by firearm" (1 in 25,263).

If you want actual data, 697 people were killed in aviation or space related accidents in 2004. That compares with 5976 pedestrians, 4018 motorcyclists, 15282 car occupants, 15494, 'Other and unspecified land transport accidents' and 17357 who were shot, stabbed or otherwise killed in an assault. And that's just the USA alone! According to the CAA in the UK, over the 1985-94 period, only 0.2 passengers were killed or seriously injured per billion passenger km flown by UK operators. This compares with 1872 on motorcycles, for example.

The fact of the matter is when you are in a large commercial plane the number of things that have to occur to cause a fatal accident are huge. It is very rarely a single issue that brings a plane down. It is usually a chain of events, missed items, mechanical issues and pilot error that all come to a point and cause the incident. Anyone who's watched National Geographic's "Air Crash Investigation' will know this. The Tenerife incident I mentioned earlier was caused by a combination of bad weather, no radar, tight crew schedules, an overbearing Captain who intimidated his crew, and a misheard radio communication. If any one of those had not been present the accident would have been avoided. Similarly, the TWA flight 800 crash was caused by the plane carrying an empty centre fuel tank coupled with decreased pressure from flying at altitude and a short circuit in a single wire (The empty fuel tank contained kerosene vapour which ignited when the spark from the short circuit met the lightly pressurised vapour). Once again a change in any of these circumstances would have prevented it (Standard operating procedure is now to keep fuel in the central tank to avoid the situation where vapour can form).

But when it comes to the smaller, general aviation planes of the type that I fly, the prospect of an incident is larger. The systems are simpler, but the pilots are less experienced (or more particularly they are less trained in all circumstances). This leads to situation where a single problem can cause an incident. In this years 'Clued Up' magazine from the CAA, Irv Lee talks about a carb icing problem he had which caused his engine to die and necessitate an emergency landing in a field. The cause of this was very simple: His student throttled back to start a decent without adding carb heat. As Irv himself says "That was the end of the flight". This wasn't a case of 3 or four things conspiring to cause an issue it was one simple mistake - a pilot error - as the student didn't follow his procedures correctly.

But again, to put all this into context, there were 14 fatal aeroplane accidents last year in the UK. The CAA believe that there were around 900,000 hours of general aviation flying in that time. That's not a bad ratio.

Of course a lot of the hoopla surrounding aviation accidents is causing many people to have a fear of flying. Most of this is to do with lack of control. But some of it is to do with not understanding how planes fly (I was on a long distance BA flight a number of years ago. As we rattled down the runway and the plane clawed it's way into the sky I shook my head in disbelief that 300 tonnes of metal, people and fuel could get airborne. The elderly lady seated next to me said 'Why are you shaking your head?"
"I fly upwards of 100 to 200 flights per year", I replied, "And I still don't really understand how it works. But it's not a problem as long as the pilot does" She smiled and leaned over to me 'It's OK", she said "The pilot know what he's doing. It's my husband"
).

One of the ways of combating this is to go on a fear of flying course. My mother took one of these recently. She used to hate flying, needed valium type pills to calm her down and remove the anxiety she was feeling. But she spent a day at Manchester Airport with British Airways and went on a 30 minute flight where the captain talked everyone through what was happening, and she nows flies 6 or 8 times a year to various destinations without any medication. It doesn't mean she likes flying, but it has removed her fear and anxiety.

So should my Australian friend be scared of flying in small aircraft? Absolutely not. They are statistically a lot safer than any other form of transport. Most occurrences are caused by pilots flying outside their comfort zone (into bad weather for example), and of the incidents that are reported, very few are fatal.

I'd rather be flying than in a car, personally!

(Graphic courtesy www.lumaxart.com/)
Technorati Tags: , , ,

26 June, 2008

Flying tip no. 3 : Carb Ice

What is carb ice: Carb ice is a phenomenon caused by cold air forming ice in the intake of your engine's carburettor. If enough ice is present it can completely cut off the air to the engine thereby causing your engine to stop (We'll go into why this happens later)

What removes it: Propeller engines have a function known as Carb Heat. This, basically, takes warm air from the exhaust and pipes it directly into the engine air intake. This has two effects

1) It removes any ice particles that are present and allows them to be ingested into the engine where they cause no harm
2) It provides warmer air to the engine which reduces it's effectiveness (it's a result of one of the laws of physics related to air pressure and temperature). This is why carb heat is not "always on".

When to use carb heat: Surprisingly enough carb icing can occur at any time of the year in just about any weather. All that are needed are two ingredients:

a) Moisture
b) A drop in temperature enough to freeze the moisture

Obviously in winter the problem is more obvious, but consider this: In a normal airplane engine intake the Venturi effect - whereby the air speeds up through the narrow intake causing a pressure change - can cause the ambient air temperature to drop by as much as 30 degrees centigrade. Given that the average summer time temperature for the UK is about 24 degrees you can see how carb ice can occur.

The most likely candidate for carb icing is on a warm summers day with good humidity when the pilot reduces power to descend from a cruise. Why?

It is caused by a combination of the sudden temperature drop due to fuel vaporisation and pressure reduction as the mixture passes through the carburettor venturi and past the throttle valve. In other words when you cut the throttle back to lose altitude it produces the two conditions needed for icing - The fuel vaporises and cools the air, and pressure in the venturi drops at the same time. If the temperature drops below the dew point then any moisture in the air will form water. If the temperature drops below the freezing point then this water will freeze.

There are many cases when carb ice should be used and the CAA safety sense leaflet Piston Engine Icing covers the cases in detail. But two points I will make as general tips:

1) Be liberal about applying carb heat before reducing power (don't be afraid to use it).
2) Don't keep carb heat on continuously (it uses air warmed on the exhaust and bypasses the air filter in doing so. This can ingest unwanted things into your engine!)

21 June, 2008

Amazing and breathtaking aviation pictures

For those of you who don't know airliners.net, it is a site containing user submitted aviation related photos. There are all sorts of (good and bad) aviation photo's on the site and I recommend a look around if this is what you're into.

The alternative is to visit this site that has collected a group of the most amazing pictures from airliners.net and published them in one place.

A lot of these are amazing because of what they represent (The threshold at Julianna Airport in the French Antilles, for example which has a beach where visitors vie to get as close as they can to the landing aircraft). But others are amazing because of what they show: A fleet of (now scrapped) Air France Concordes, or an American jet fighter at zero altitude with wheels up.

I would be interested to know your favourites.

20 June, 2008

Farnborough seeks to increase yearly movements

In news today Farnborough Airport (the largest dedicated business aviation airport in the UK) is looking to increase the number of aircraft movements it is allowed.

At the moment the local council is capping the number of movements at 28,000 movements annually. Considering this includes ALL weekend movements AND the airshow, this is a particularly small number of movements for such a large airport.

The reason the upgrade is needed is (as quoted by a Farnborough spokesperson)
"Between May 2007 and May 2008 we saw a 60% increase in airliner-size business jets at Farnborough alone,"
Not surprisingly the local council will need to look into this in light of complaints about noise, air quality and safety (Farnborough is, after all, surrounded on most sides by built up areas and approaches from the east are over heavily populated areas. The Westerly approach is less populated, but does overfly the Odiham RAF base).

According to Farnborough themselves they could accommodate 100,000 movements a year but will settle for about half that.

In my recent visit to Farnborough ATC I chatted with a few of the controllers there who said that they are under conflicting pressure from the users and the local residents. The users feel that the number of movements is artificially capped (and as such is causing them business issues) and the local users are, understandably, concerned about the affect of doubling the number of aircraft movements. Remember Farnborough generally deals with corporate/business jet aviation and - on my last visit there - had over 20 Gulfstream jets alone on the tarmac. We're not talking about weekend flyers in piper Warriers and Cessna 150's!

I'll keep an eye out on this one for you.

17 June, 2008

The qualifying cross country flight.. (Or how not to get lost when there's no street signs)


(picture courtesy Les Chatfield)

For many student pilots, the qualifying cross country flight (QXC) is a daunting experience. It's your first long flight alone, you're visiting airfields you might be unfamiliar with and - on top of all that - you've actually got to do the navigation!

No wonder many students dread the experience.

But never fear, in a few moments I'm going to give you a couple of tips to reduce the stress and eliminate the fear. First want to tell you about my QXC

I did my QXC in Florida. Now for those of you who've never been to Florida let me try and describe the land.

Flat.

Featureless

Flat and featureless.

Sure there are some towns there (Orlando being the main one I was focused on) but outside of that it's just flat and featureless. Occasionally you'll come across a body of water (actually quite a lot of bodies of water) but they are so indistinct as to be almost unusable for navigation. (As an exercise, go to Google Maps and type in "Land o' lakes, Florida", click on satellite and see what the ground looks like.)

Needless to say this makes the QXC a bit of a challenge. The key in this case is to make sure you are flying on the right track and keep a careful control of your timing. For example on the first leg of my QXC (Kissimmee to Ocala), I knew that I needed to position myself just left of Magic Mountain and take a particular heading for a length of time. This would bring me to the edge of Eastlake Weir which had hwy 42 running South and hwy 441 running west of it. The key was knowing that as long as I kept the direction and distance I would arrive at the lake. It was big enough to act as a navigation point and I could correct any drift as and when the lake came in sight.

Remember the key thing about the QXC: It's not meant to check how well you can follow a line on a map. It's meant to check how well you can navigate from point A to point B. This includes making navigation corrections when you go off track. As an example, when I first flew the QXC route I did it with my instructor. We got to Crystal River (which is a lovely place on the Gulf Coast with a friendly little airport) and the next stop was back to Orlando. However, as we took off from Crystal River my instructor noticed that the Gulf coast was actually a lot of reclaimed land that had huge, expensive houses on them, so we went for a little cruise over the bay to check out the houses.

Then
I started navigating back to Orlando.

Of course at that point all my calculations were completely hopeless. I was starting from the wrong place and on the wrong heading. My instructor knew this, of course, and said nothing. I just followed my original track and kept checking the map vs the ground below to determine where I was in relation to where I should have been. About 15 minutes into the leg I finally located our actual track and was able to make adjustments. We made it back to Orlando in time to circle the airport for 20 minutes waiting for the business jets flying into Disney for the weekend to land!

Anyway back to the tips:
Tip 1: Aviate, Navigate, Communicate

It's the old adage. Make sure you fly the plane first and foremost. Keep doing your FREDA checks. Ensure you're flying straight and level at the height you planned and the speed you planned. There is no excuse for not making sure your number one priority is to actually fly the plane.

Tip 2: Plan, Plan, Plan
The key to making a good QXC is to plan, plan, plan. Have your route plotted thoroughly before hand. Mark it in pencil on your map - heavy black pencil so you can see it. At the start of each leg write the heading and expected flight time in a box as an easy reference. Mark expected landmarks you wish to navigate by (river and road crossings, major arterial highways, castles, masts, odd geographical features etc). Consult Google Maps or Microsoft Maps in satellite mode to see what the landmarks look like from the air. Have all the appropriate radio frequencies to hand. Draw a layout of the destination airports to know where the runways are and what the joining instructions are likely to be. Be prepared.

Tip 3: Fly the route before hand
Nothing beats having flown somewhere before to give you a feeling of experience. Your QXC needs to be at least 150nm to 2 separate airports one of which is 50nm from the other. This sounds imposing but really, it's a flight to an airport in the distance, a second flight to a nearby airport and then a long trek back home. If you think of it in those terms it's not so bad. With your instructor, find the ideal locations to fly to. He or she will help you with the planning of your pre-QXC flight and this will make the actual flight itself far easier.

Tip 4: Chose easy airports to fly to.
Depending on where you're located, it's not always easy to find good airports to fly to. But for your QXC you need fields that are not too big (otherwise you end up paying high landing charges AND have to deal with air traffic control etc. This can generally cut out places like Shoreham and Bournemouth) but not too small that they are hard to see visibly from the air (Flying to Popham or Old Sarum, for example is difficult if you don't know what you're looking for or where it is). Find a reasonably sized airfield with a hard runway if possible: Bembridge, Blackbushe, Thruxton, Wellsbourne Mountford, Oxford, or Lydd are good examples down South. Also find airfields that are not close to controlled airspace (Fairoaks is a lovely field with a long hard runway, but is under the Heathrow Class A airspace: it's an added distraction you don't need on your QXC)

Tip 5: Read Jeremy Pratt's 'Navigation Meteorology' part of the Private Pilots Licence Course handbooks.
Apart from having a wealth of information and additional tips he has also added a section called 'Visual Navigation - A Practical Example' (pp nav83 to nav91) which takes you through a complete flight using map extracts and photographs of ground features to help identify navigation features etc. This is extremely useful as a means of focusing the mind on the correct navigation items and the correct mindset.

Navigation in itself is not difficult. Flying an aircraft along a straight and level flight in itself is not difficult. Speaking to ATC on the radio in itself is not difficult. The difficulty comes when you are trying to do all three at the same time. This is what makes the QXC flight so daunting. Follow the tips above and these will, hopefully, give you an added level of confidence to offset the trepidation.

15 June, 2008

Autogyro!

So here I am at a very busy Blackbushe trying to avoid a load of cub scouts waiting for a quick local flight over their house and I see this Autogyro.

It's something of a first for me as I've never actually seen one live. In fact the nearest I've been to one is watching "You're Only Young Twice" with Ken Wallis flying Little Nellie across Japan. So it's something of a rarity to see a real, live version!

Wonder what they're like to fly?

13 June, 2008

Flying on nothing but fumes and... algae?

Boeing have recently announced that they are promoting the use of algae based fuels in their engines. Or to be more precise they are looking at using algae based energy sources as a means of replacing the worlds reliance on fossil fuels for aviation. The logic behind this is quite simple: Raw algae is fast growing and does not need fresh water. It also doesn't conflict with food quotas (a charge often leveled at biofuels made from corn, for example) This in turn won't drive up the price of food in the short term. With some experts predicting oil will rise to $400 per barrel this makes financial sense.

Of course it is one thing to test a particular fuel in a particular engine on a single flight (as Virgin Atlantic did recently), but in order to make Algae biofuel viable there has to be a supporting infrastructure according to a steering committee of the Algal Biomass Organization, a nonprofit that promotes and advocates for the development of commercially viable transportation fuels.

In order to achieve that viability, Algae-based fuels need a supply chain the committee says, adding such fuels are in the early stages of development. The organization aims to accelerate the development of such power sources.

Over the coming months both Air New Zealand and Continental will make test flights using biofuel in one of the engines, and Virgin Atlantic is hoping a trial can be performed using algae as a biofuel source next year.

How quickly before this filters down to the average Lycoming or Continental engine used in GA...?

Apture